|
Assessment of the Downstream Passage of Juvenile Salmonids Through the Powerhouse, Sluiceway and Spillway of the Dalles Dam
The Problem
 |
| The
Dalles Dam. Photo courtesy of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. |
The National Marine Fisheries Services Biological Opinion on the Columbia River
salmon listed under the Endangered Species Act sets guidelines for
salmon recovery. Many of the guidelines address salmon passage issues
at hydroelectric dams operated by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
(COE), because fish passing through turbines experience higher mortality
than those that go over the spillway. To meet these guidelines,
the COE has undertaken a series of studies to improve downstream
passage conditions for juvenile salmonids. There are currently no
structural methods employed to divert juvenile fish from turbine
entrainment at The
Dalles Dam, because the ice-trash sluiceway and spillway have
been more effective at this dam than at most others. However, even
during periods of 30 to 40% spill, turbine entrainment is often
approximately 15% during the night, indicating some type of additional
measure is warranted. The most recent such measure has been installation
and testing of "J"-design turbine intake occlusion structures. These
were used in an effort to reduce turbine entrainment by blocking
off the upper half of the turbine intakes.
Objectives
The objective of this study is to determine the approach pattern and passage locations of juvenile salmonids to assist in planning decisions relative to a behavioral guidance structure at The Dalles Dam. This will be accomplished by comparing estimates of fish, spill and sluiceway passage efficiencies of fish with different approach patterns. The approach patterns will be determined using three in-river telemetry arrays.
Methodology
This study is based on radio-tagged juvenile chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus
tshawytscha) and steelhead (O. mykiss) released approximately
50 km upstream. A series of underwater and aerial antennas connected to
data logging telemetry receiving systems will be used to detect the fish
as they
approach and pass the dam, enabling the proportions of fish passing each
route (i.e., turbines, sluiceway, or spillway) to be determined. In FY2002
approximately 3500 yearling chinook salmon, 3500 juvenile steelhead and
7000 subyearling chinook salmon were released upstream this and other
studies conducted by the USGS in the vicinity. The overall fish passage
efficiency (the proportion of fish passing
 |
| Downloading
an aerial antenna receiver downriver of The Dalles Dam. |
via all non-turbine routes),
spill passage efficiency (the proportion of fish passing via the spillway)
and spill passage effectiveness (the spill passage efficiency divided
by the proportion of water spilled), as well as similar measures of passage
via the sluiceway are calculated during each treatment level. The treatment
levels are changed every two days throughout the study period, which is
about 4 weeks in the spring and 4 weeks in the summer. Statistical comparisons
between treatment levels, by species and day/night periods are made using
Chi-Square or F-tests following a logistic regression procedure.
Highlights and Key Findings
Assessments of juvenile salmonid passage studies at The Dalles Dam were conducted in 1999, 2000, 2001 and 2002. Data from 2000, testing 40% spill and the juvenile pattern, indicated that juvenile chinook salmon had a fish passage efficiency (FPE) of 84.7% and a juvenile steelhead FPE of 91.2%. The spill passage efficiencies (SPE) were 79.3 and 85.4%, respectively. Sluiceway passage efficiencies (SLPE) were 5.5 and 5.8%. The FPE, SPE, and SLPE estimates from subyearling chinook salmon during 2000 were 88, 77, and 11%, respectively. Data from 2001, tests of J-design intake occlusion plates, were inconclusive due to variation from study protocols. Results of the 2002 study testing the occlusion plates indicated reductions in turbine passage of yearling chinook salmon and subyearling chinook salmon, but not wild steelhead.
Data collected during 40% spill in 2000 were typically more similar to those collected during 64% than at 30% spill in 1999 (Table 1). Fish passage efficiencies of yearling chinook salmon during 40% spill were intermediate to those during 30% and 64% spill, but those of juvenile steelhead were similar during all spill percentages tested. Spill passage efficiencies during 40% spill were very similar to those during 64% spill and SLPE was lower during 40% spill than during the other treatments. Data from 2002 indicated that overall FPE and SPE were similar to previous years during like spill conditions (Table 1). Data from underwater antennas at the powerhouse indicated turbine passage of yearling and subyearling chinook salmon was significantly lower during the occluded treatment level.
Table
1. Passage metrics determined from USGS radio-telemetry studies
at The Dalles Dam during 1999, 2000 and 2002. Data from 2002 are
listed as "occluded%, unoccluded%" to describe the intake
occlusion plate position. |
Metric |
Percent spill (Year) |
Yearling
Chinook |
Juvenile Steelhead |
Subyearling
Chinook |
| |
|
|
|
|
FPE |
30 (1999) |
74% |
91% |
N/A |
|
30 (2002) |
73%, 67% |
91%, 87% |
71%, 58% |
|
40 (2000) |
85% |
91% |
88% |
|
64 (1999) |
91% |
95% |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
|
SPE |
30 (1999) |
51% |
66% |
N/A |
|
30 (2002) |
65%, 56% |
80%, 69% |
62%, 51% |
|
40 (2000) |
79% |
85% |
77% |
|
64 (1999) |
79% |
86% |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
|
SLPE |
30 (1999) |
22% |
25% |
N/A |
|
30 (2002) |
10%, 11% |
12%, 18% |
9%, 7% |
|
40 (2000) |
6% |
6% |
10% |
|
64 (1999) |
12% |
9% |
N/A |
Where Are We Headed In 2003
The approach patterns and subsequent passage locations of juvenile salmonids will be determined in 2003 to provide data regional fishery managers can use to assess the utility of the use of a behavioral guidance structure and The Dalles Dam in the future. Detected fish will also be used in USGS studies of salmon survival.
Project Contact
John Beeman
U.S. Geological Survey
Western Fisheries Research Center
Columbia River Research Laboratory
5501-A Cook-Underwood Rd.
Cook, WA 98605-9717
Email: john_beeman@usgs.gov
Phone: 509-538-2299 x257
Fax: 509-538-2843
Publications
|